As investor interest in Cayman Islands real estate continues to rise, understanding rental yield trends — the annual rental income as a percentage of property purchase price — has become increasingly essential for informed decision-making.
While the Cayman Islands Real Estate Brokers Association (CIREBA) primarily tracks sales activity through its Multiple Listing System (MLS), insights from on-the-ground real estate agents and other economic data can offer a reliable picture of how rental returns are performing across Grand Cayman in 2025.
Understanding the rental yield landscape
Although rental figures are not directly tracked, CIREBA’s market data shows that residential sales volumes remained stable through early 2025, driving much of the momentum in Cayman Islands real estate.
“Typical gross rental yields for residential properties tend to hover between 5% and 7%, depending heavily on location, property type and fit and finish,” observes ERA Cayman associate broker John Pohlmann, who has over a decade of professional experience with Cayman real estate.
“In 2025, the average gross yield across Cayman is pegged roughly at 5.3%,” he explains. “Popular areas like Seven Mile Beach, George Town, and West Bay show the strongest performance at 6% to 7%, especially for smaller units and short-term rentals. At Seven Mile Beach, yields often exceed 7% for one-bedroom condos due to consistently high demand.”
At the other end of the market, John points out that larger luxury homes tend to offer lower percentage returns — typically 4% to 5% — as high purchase prices outpace rental income. However, these properties often compensate with strong capital appreciation and liquidity.
Neighborhoods leading the way in 2025
Among Grand Cayman’s districts, West Bay and Savannah/Newlands are emerging as rental yield leaders this year.
“West Bay continues to attract both long-term residents and new arrivals,” notes ERA Cayman sales agent Selene Oddenino-Newton. “It offers a growing inventory of modern apartments and good proximity to Seven Mile Beach without the premium price tag. Yields are particularly strong for newer one- and two-bedroom units where rental demand remains high.”
Savannah and Newlands, she adds, have been performing well in the mid-range segment, particularly among families and professionals seeking more space and quieter surroundings within easy reach of George Town. “Properties purchased at lower price points in these areas often deliver solid returns relative to rental income,” she says.
Meanwhile, the Seven Mile Beach corridor remains Cayman’s premium market, enjoying exceptionally low vacancy rates and steady occupancy from both short-term visitors and corporate tenants. However, Selene points out: “Yields are naturally compressed due to high property values, so investors here are trading off higher upfront costs for stability and long-term appreciation.”
On the other hand, John cites districts like Bodden Town and East End as among the areas that deliver slightly lower but still competitive yields — typically around 5% to 6%, where lower property prices help offset the slower pace of rental demand.
“On Cayman Brac, yields can reach 6% to 7% for modest homes catering to long-term tenants, though liquidity is lower,” he adds. “Meanwhile, Little Cayman offers similar percentages but from fewer rentals, mostly from seasonal or eco-tourism lets.”
Evolving tenant preferences
Rental performance is also being influenced and reshaped by shifts in tenant expectations. Both ERA agents agree that today’s renters are more discerning and value-driven than ever before.
“Tenants are increasingly looking for energy-efficient homes,” Selene shares. “Those with solar panels, inverter air-conditioning, and good insulation get increasing attention. Fully furnished, turnkey rentals are also in demand, especially among professionals relocating for short or medium terms.”
She also notices that pet-friendly properties and units offering modern amenities like pools, gyms, and secure parking continue to command higher occupancy rates and marginally better yields.
Beyond features, however, neighborhood reputation and lifestyle now play a significant role.
“People want safety, convenience, and community,” says Richard Newton, also a sales professional with ERA Cayman. “Areas like West Bay or the South Sound fringe, which offer that balance, are seeing stronger rental demand.”
These evolving preferences are prompting landlords to invest in upgrades and modernizations, ensuring their properties remain competitive.
“Investors who adapt quickly to these shifts are enjoying better retention and returns,” he avers.
Emerging areas for long-term growth
For investors looking beyond Grand Cayman’s traditional hotspots, up-and-coming neighborhoods present exciting opportunities for long-term rental growth.
Selene cites Bodden Town and Lower Valley as among those that stand out, due to their continuing infrastructure improvements, new schools, and expanding community amenities. “Prices are still accessible compared to the western districts,” she says, “which translates into higher potential yields relative to cost.”
East End and North Side are also gaining attention from niche investors targeting eco-tourism or remote-work tenants. Enhanced internet connectivity and road upgrades are helping these districts shed their “far-flung” perception.
Meanwhile, George Town East (Prospect and Red Bay) is another emerging zone to watch. The upcoming Red Bay Plaza development, which will introduce new commercial and retail spaces, is expected to increase demand for nearby rentals as more professionals and businesses move into the area. “This new hub, combined with easy access to the city and South Sound, positions Red Bay as one of the next growth pockets for both capital appreciation and rental returns,” notes Selene.
“Overall, these emerging areas offer a balanced mix of affordability, convenience, and future growth, making them strong contenders for investors seeking sustainable rental yields over the next five to ten years,” she opines.
Competitive rental yields
For those considering property in the Cayman Islands as a rental investment, 2025 offers a particularly favorable landscape.
Rental yields remain competitive by global standards, especially when viewed alongside Cayman’s steady property value appreciation and year-round occupancy rates. With the islands’ growing population, expanding professional workforce, and ongoing infrastructure improvements, investors have been benefiting from both consistent rental income and long-term capital growth.
Beyond the numbers, owning an investment property in Cayman means participating in a market renowned for its transparency, well-regulated real estate practices, and high standard of living.
If you’re exploring property investment in the Cayman Islands, our trusted and experienced sales agents at Team ERA Cayman are here to help you find that ideal balance between quality of life and steady returns. With our deep market insight and experience, we can help you make informed decisions in a rental market that continues to remain both stable and rewarding. Call us today!
Inquire for More Information
